Welcome to Body Confidential
Reset Password

You are here: Body ConfidentialHealth.

It's breast cancer awareness month...

...but the pink ribbon glosses over unpalatable truths, says Liverpool author Sarah Horton

Published on October 8th 2010.


It's breast cancer awareness month...

IT'S hard to escape the fact that October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month. Do we need any more awareness? Doesn’t everyone know that breast cancer is everywhere?

When I see breast cancer charities and companies selling pink ribbon products I think it puts a gloss over the terror of breast cancer, promoting cheerfulness and acceptance in the face of this mutilating disease which now affects one in every nine women.

If the breast cancer movement aligned itself with worries about the environment, it would link the pink ribbon with anti-corporate social movements, something the pink brigade don't seem to want to do

And as far as I can see, it seems to be breast cancer month all year round, making the need for this October “festival” almost redundant.

There is always a fundraising event going on for breast cancer, usually a load of women in pink, cheerfully and bravely doing their bit to “beat” the disease. And yet, the disease statistics continue to rise. Awareness on its own is simply not enough.

When I was diagnosed, everyone I spoke to knew someone who’d had a breast cancer experience. And mostly their response was not shock, no, it was just a sympathetic nod. Oh, so it’s my turn now is it?

And during breast cancer awareness month we’re told that a “cure” is just around the corner. So, how does that make me feel? Well, I was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2007, aged 43, and I will never hear that word spoken to me by any of my doctors – “cure”. Because we can’t cure breast cancer. Even successfully treated, it will carry the chance of recurrence, forever.

Breast cancer continues to be simplistically portrayed by the media. In fact this disease is a range of different types of cancers, all with diverse characteristics and treatments, It would therefore need several different cures – not one catch-all, nice and simple “cure for cancer”.

The media portrays breast cancer as a treatable disease. But the reality of treatment is far from pleasant. I’ve has six surgeries, at the hands of my brilliant NHS doctors, including mastectomy, oophorectomy and breast reconstruction, and spent hours of my life in hospital, and my treatment is still not finished.

I have been terrified, feared my own death, an early death. I have felt ill and exhausted and mentally drained. All of this, and felt like three years of my life has been lost, lost to this disease. Breast cancer kicked a hole in my life that’s so big I can’t see the edge.

That’s why I would much rather stop the disease happening in the first place. Put the focus on prevention. Because if we don’t, and if breast cancer incidence continues to rise, as it has done for the last 60 years, then it’s going to be even more common. That’s not the future I want for our daughters and granddaughters, our sisters and mothers.

There are now clear arguments about the causes of breast cancer, pointing to suspicions about carcinogens in the environment, food, alcohol and cosmetics.

Other writers have suggested that if the breast cancer movement aligned itself with worries about the environment, it would link the pink ribbon with anti-corporate social movements, something the pink brigade don’t seem to want to do. The cheerful pink gloss is covering up the reality of this killer disease.

After diagnosis I felt I was on a conveyor belt, just being processed as yet another one of the 46,000 women in the UK who are diagnosed with breast cancer each year. I fiercely resisted the ‘accepted route’ which tried to ensure my experience of the disease was feminine and palatable. I felt rage. I felt anger. And yet it did not seem that being angry was supposed to be OK. Anger should have an important place within breast cancer culture.

If we get angry then maybe we’ll finally get a breast cancer movement where there is real pressure to look for the causes of and prevent this disease.

Being Sarah by Sarah Horton, documents the Liverpool author's struggle to find choice and control over her treatment. It is published by Wordscapes (£8.99, 271pp) on 7 October 2010 and is available at www.beingsarah.com or to order from bookshops.

Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great videos, food reviews, news, deals and savings.

JamesOctober 11th 2010.

My mother has been through three bouts of breast cancer and is now deemed terminally ill after it spread to her spine and hips. Over the last year I have done a great deal of research on the internet regarding alternative cures. I have come across the PH Miracle Diet, as promoted by Dr Robert Young and his wife Shelley. Whereas you may immediately feel this sounds like a gimmick, it is focused entirely on the notion that cancer is in fact a resulty of over-acidification of the body which continuously tries to keep its PH balance at its natural alkaline level to the detriment of other cells in the body. It involves a lifestyle overhaul and eating alkaline producing foods (such as very green raw vegetables). This is nothing new, in the past even Nobel Prize for medicine winners have spoken on cancer thriving in an acidic environment and the need for oxygen in the cells (which these foods provide) . While I have serious doubts about the conventional treatments, my mother's life has been extended by drugs such as Herceptin and therefore I believe a combination of medical and natural treatments is important. I would very much ask anyone who is suffering, or knows somebody that is, to research this theory heavily. My mother is three weeks into this new lifestyle overhaul and already her symproms have lessened and her appetite has returned. I remain hopeful that we have not started this too late. Please do the research and come to your own conclusion, on the Internet there are fantastic testimonials (youtube), this is not a fad, it is a diet based on quality foods that starve the cancer and boost your immune system in your fight. If anyone is intertested then please respond to this post and I will come back to you with my contact details. James

Sue11015October 11th 2010.

Twenty years ago I got married. That very same month I found a malignant lump in my breast, three weeks before our wedding. I was told not to plan a family. I was devastated, to say the least, and have my husband-to-be the opportunity to leave me and find someone that he could have children with. He stayed with me.

Eighteen months later my first child was born! I had caught the cancer early and treatment did not affect my fertility. My second child arrived sixteen months later.

Why me? Who knows. But I am now passionate about supporting The Genesis Appeal, who are the only charity in the UK entirely dedicated to the prevention of breast cancer.

So, this week where I work we are holding a fundraising event. We call it our Sparkle Night. I don't want my daughter to go through what I went through.

AnonymousOctober 15th 2010.

but there IS a movement that looks at the causes and prevention of breast cancer. manchester's genesis appeal focuses on precisely these issues.
for more information visit
http://www.genesisuk.org

To post this comment, you need to login.Please complete your login information.
OR CREATE AN ACCOUNT HERE..
Or you can login using Facebook.

Explore The Site

© Confidential Publishing 2012

Privacy | Careers | Website by: Planet Code